Two Fed Voices, One Direction: Waller and Bowman on the Case for a December Move

Key takeaways
- Inflation persistence: Core PCE inflation likely rose to 3.3 percent in October (federalreserve.gov).
- Labor market strength: The unemployment rate decreased to 4.1 percent in October (federalreserve.gov).
- Policy stance: Governor Waller would support a 25 basis point increase in December if inflation improves as expected (federalreserve.gov).
- Financial tightening: Equity valuations in the tech sector have decreased as investors reassess returns and AI investment risks (federalreserve.gov).
The Federal Reserve is facing a complex intersection of labor market resilience and persistent price pressures. According to the Federal Reserve, core PCE inflation likely rose to 3.3 percent in October (federalreserve.gov). This figure follows a September reading where core PCE inflation rose 0.3 percent and 3.1 percent from the previous year (federalreserve.gov). As the Committee approaches its December meeting, the debate centers on whether recent tightening in financial conditions will sufficiently dampen inflation or if a policy rate increase is required to meet the 2 percent price stability target (federalreserve.gov).
The case for a December hike: Waller and Bowman
Recent commentary from Federal Reserve officials suggests a growing inclination toward further tightening. Governor Waller has indicated a willingness to support a 25 basis point increase in the FOMC policy rate at the December meeting, provided that inflation improves as expected (federalreserve.gov). This stance is reinforced by the persistent nature of service sector inflation. In September, more than 70 percent of core PCE service price components saw 12-month increases above 3 percent (federalreserve.gov).
The argument for a hike rests on the "sticky" nature of these service prices. When a large majority of service components remain well above the 2 percent target, the risk of inflation expectations becoming unanchored increases. Also, the labor market continues to show strength. The unemployment rate decreased to 4.1 percent in October (federalreserve.gov). While job gains have moderated, with 6-month and 12-month averages hovering near 80,000 jobs per month, the economy has still added 165,000 jobs in October, which included an 85,000 job upward revision to the previous two months' estimates (federalreserve.gov).
Why It Matters: The composition of inflation is shifting from goods to services, where wage growth and service demand create more persistent price pressures.
Key Insight
The transmission mechanism: Financial conditions and tech valuations
A critical component of the current economic environment is the unexpected tightening of financial conditions. The Federal Reserve notes that financial conditions have tightened due to lower equity prices, higher private interest rates, and a stronger dollar (federalreserve.gov). A significant driver of this volatility is the technology sector. Equity valuations in the tech sector have decreased as investors reassess returns and AI investment risks (federalreserve.gov).
This creates a complex feedback loop for the Fed. On one hand, the decline in tech valuations and the strengthening dollar act as "automatic" monetary tightening, potentially slowing investment and consumption without a formal rate move. On the other hand, the Fed must decide if these market-driven tightening effects are sufficient to offset the inflationary pressures seen in energy and services. For example, Brent oil prices rose to or above $110 per barrel during the second half of October (federalreserve.gov).
How to read the inflation numbers
To understand the Fed's dilemma, one must distinguish between the different measures of inflation. Personal consumption expenditures (PCE) inflation measures the change in the price of goods and services consumed by households. Core PCE excludes volatile food and energy components to provide a clearer view of long-term trends (federalreserve.gov). While the headline PCE inflation rose at a monthly rate of 0.5 percent in September, the focus for policymakers is often the core metric, which rose 0.3 percent in that same month (federalreserve.gov).
Analysis: The tension between labor and prices
The Fed's dual mandate requires balancing stable prices with maximum employment (federalreserve.gov). Currently, these two goals appear to be in tension. The labor market remains tight, with the unemployment rate at 4.1 percent (federalreserve.gov). However, a secondary indicator suggests underlying weakness in specific sectors. The three-month moving average of workers unemployed for 27 weeks or more increased from 18 percent at the end of 2022 to over 27 percent through September 2026 (federalreserve.gov).
This divergence suggests a "composition effect" in the labor market. While the headline unemployment rate remains low, long-term unemployment is rising. This could indicate that while new jobs are being created, workers are staying unemployed longer once they lose their positions. For an executive, this means the "headline" strength of the consumer may mask a growing fragility in the long-term labor supply.
| Metric | September 2026 Value | October 2026 Value |
|---|---|---|
| Unemployment Rate | Not specified | 4.1% (federalreserve.gov) |
| Core PCE (Year-over-Year) | 3.1% (federalreserve.gov) | 3.3% (Likely) (federalreserve.gov) |
| Monthly Job Gains | 85,000 (Revision) (federalreserve.gov) | 165,000 (federalreserve.gov) |
| Wage/Salary Cost Index (ECI) | 3.1% (federalreserve.gov) | Not specified |
The counter-reading: Is the Fed over-tightening?
The argument against a December hike is rooted in the risk of "over-tightening" the economy. Chairman Warsh noted in an October 28 press conference that while overall financial conditions are tighter, he is unwilling to call them "tight" (federalreserve.gov). This nuance is vital. If the Fed raises rates in December, they would be adding to the existing tightening seen in private interest rates and equity markets (federalreserve.gov).
Also, credit conditions are already showing signs of stress. The October Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey on Bank Lending Practices indicated demand weakness in real estate loan categories (federalreserve.gov). If the Fed raises rates while the real estate sector is already seeing weakened demand, they risk a more significant contraction in credit availability than intended. The risk is that the "dose of accommodation" removed in previous actions, combined with a December hike, might lead to a sharper-than-expected slowdown in capital expenditure (federalreserve.gov).
Watch For: The impact of AI-related price pressures, which currently account for approximately one-fourth of above-target core PCE inflation (federalreserve.gov).
Why It Matters
Analysis: Scenario Comparison
To assist in strategic planning, we compare two likely paths for the end of the year.
- Scenario A: The Hawkish Pivot. The Fed implements a 25 basis point hike in December (federalreserve.gov). This assumes that inflation is too high to ignore and that the tech-driven equity volatility is not enough to curb price pressures. This would likely lead to further tightening in credit markets and potentially more pressure on high-growth sectors.
- Scenario B: The Wait-and-See Approach. The Fed holds rates steady, monitoring whether the current tightening in financial conditions and the decline in tech valuations are enough to bring core PCE back toward the 2 percent target (federalreserve.gov). This scenario carries the risk of inflation becoming entrenched, particularly in the service sector.
What it means for industry strategy
For executives and policymakers, the current data suggests three primary strategic considerations:
- Capital Allocation and AI Risk: With tech valuations reassessing AI investment risks and AI-related pressures accounting for a quarter of core inflation (federalreserve.gov), firms should scrutinize the immediate ROI of AI deployments. The market is no longer rewarding "AI potential" without clear evidence of productivity gains.
- Liquidity and Credit Management: Given the demand weakness in real estate loans and the trend of tightening financial conditions, firms should prioritize liquidity and avoid over-reliance on variable-rate credit (federalreserve.gov).
- Cost Structure and Wage Pressure: With service price components frequently exceeding 3 percent, companies with high service-based overhead should prepare for persistent input cost inflation, even if headline goods inflation stabilizes (federalreserve.gov).
Looking ahead: Key indicators to monitor
The decision in December will likely hinge on three specific data points. First, the November PCE print will confirm if the 3.3 percent core inflation in October was a transitory spike or a trend (federalreserve.gov). Second, the next Senior Loan Officer Survey will indicate if the demand weakness in real estate is spreading to other commercial credit categories (federalreserve.gov). Finally, the Federal Reserve's assessment of whether "financial conditions" have crossed the threshold from "tighter" to "tight" will be the ultimate signal for the December meeting (federalreserve.gov).